Selling · Updated this year
Consignment versus selling it yourself
What a dealer actually does for the commission, and when you are better off not paying it.
We take cars on consignment, so treat this as an interested party being straight with you rather than neutral advice.
When selling it yourself makes sense
If the car is common, priced under about twenty thousand dollars, and you have the patience to answer messages from people who will never buy it, sell it yourself. The commission on a car at that price is not buying you much you cannot do.
What the commission is actually paying for
A full photographic record. Shooting a car properly takes most of a day and a building with the right light.
Placement on the marketplaces buyers actually search, kept current rather than posted once.
Somebody answering the phone at eight on a Sunday evening, which is when people shop for cars.
Filtering. Most enquiries on a collector car are not buyers, and finding out costs time.
The paperwork, the funds transfer and the transport, done in an order that does not leave you exposed.
The questions to ask any consignment dealer
What is the commission, and is it a percentage or a fixed figure? Who pays for transport in, photography and storage? What happens if it does not sell — is there a floor price, and can you take the car back? Is the car insured while it sits on their floor, and under what policy? Where exactly will it be listed? Get the answers in writing before the car leaves.
Price it where it will sell, not where you hope
The single most common reason a consigned car does not move is that the owner set the number from the highest auction result they could find for a better example. Sold prices matter; asking prices do not.
Questions about a specific car?
Text us. We will send photos, a video, or a straight answer about a car you are considering — even one you are buying somewhere else.